Warm oak floors and cream furnishings in a modest older home's living room, opening into a softly lit dining room in late autumn.

What a Square Foot Costs in Solvay and Geddes This Year

716 Scarboro Drive appeared on the Solvay school district's public sales record three times in 2026. The January transfers put it at $160,000 for 2,237 square feet, about $72 a foot, listed with three bedrooms and two baths. In the April transfers it was $170,000, or $76 a foot, now with four bedrooms. By August it sold for $282,000, which works out to $126 a foot. That August sale was also the district's median for the month.

The square footage stayed the same through all three sales, while the price grew by $122,000 and moved from one of the lowest per-foot figures in the district to the middle. Whatever buyers were paying for between January and August, it was not floor space, and the rest of this year's Solvay-area sales point the same way. In this part of Geddes, square footage has only a weak effect on price, so a price-per-foot number can mislead a buyer comparing listings.

A 1,040-square-foot house and a 3,077-square-foot house sold about $6,000 apart

This Is CNY publishes a monthly list of every recorded residential transfer in the Solvay Union Free School District, built from ATTOM property data. Each entry shows price, square footage and bedrooms. Put the 2026 lists side by side and the same pattern keeps showing up.

In the August transfers, 611 3rd St. sold for $214,240. It has 1,040 square feet and three bedrooms. In the September transfers, 101 4th St. sold for $220,000 with 3,077 square feet, five bedrooms and three baths. Both sit on the village's numbered streets, and they sold within about $6,000 of each other, yet the second has nearly three times the floor space. Per foot, they come to $206 and $71.

Other pairs from the same two months show the same thing. 109 1st St. sold for $258,000 in the August transfers with 2,016 square feet and five bedrooms. 106 Sharon Road sold for $263,000 in September with 1,086 square feet and three bedrooms. In that September list, 204 7th St. brought $251,000 for 2,240 square feet and six bedrooms. 109 Bury Drive brought $260,100 for 1,336 square feet and three bedrooms, and Bury Drive was the month's median sale for the district.

So for roughly $250,000 to $265,000 in late summer 2026, nearly identical checks bought about 1,100 square feet in one sale and more than 2,000 in another.

The highest per-foot prices are on the smallest houses

Sort the 2026 lists by price per foot and the top is almost all compact three-bedroom houses of about 1,000 to 1,200 square feet. 124 Alhan Parkway sold at $270 a foot and 13 Birch Road at $249 in the March transfers. 105 Benoit Drive came in at $259 in January. In August, 116 Huntshill Road sold at $255 a foot and 206 Salisbury Road at $244. Each sold for about $290,000.

The numbered streets show this too, so it isn't only a matter of neighborhood. 210 7th St. has 832 square feet and sold for $162,500 in the March transfers, which is $195 a foot. That is more per foot than any house over 2,000 square feet on those streets brought this year. What the small houses have in common is their size. Each one fits under the same price range buyers in this district have been paying, and dividing that price by a small footprint gives a high number.

The large houses that did bring strong per-foot prices this year came with more bathrooms. 525 N. Orchard Road sold for $462,500 in the August transfers with 2,616 square feet, or $177 a foot. 61 Hardwicke Drive sold for $440,500 in April with 2,335 square feet, or $189 a foot. Each has four bathrooms. The big houses that sold under $130 a foot this year had one to three.

The village streets were built for a different century of buying

The amount of house on the older streets near Milton Avenue goes back to the plant those streets grew up around. The Town of Geddes's own history dates the Solvay Process works to 1881 and credits it with much of the area's growth. In 2025 the state nominated the 1917 Pozzi Building on Milton Avenue to the historic registers. The Governor's announcement describes it as a residential hotel where Tyrolean immigrant men rented rooms while they worked at Solvay Process across the street.

The village's housing still carries more multi-unit buildings than the rest of the town. The 2019 Envision Geddes and Solvay plan, drawing on 2016 Census figures, reported two-unit buildings at 18.8% of the village's housing compared with 9.0% across the town.

The land to the south and west was developed later. Westvale was farm country around the Parsons cherry orchard, and residents raised money in 1925 for Cherry Road School, which opened in 1927, according to syracuse.com's account of a Solvay-Geddes Historical Society alumni event. The Solvay Public Library's archive includes subdivision plans for Upland Farms in the Town of Geddes dated 1937, 1946 and 1949 to 1950. The district's 2026 sales lists draw on houses from both of these building eras.

The bottom of the range is not a market price

The lowest per-foot sales in the 2026 lists are the ones most likely to throw off a buyer's comparison. 140 Worth Ave. sold for $65,000 for 1,582 square feet in the August transfers, which is $35 a foot. 122 Alice Ave. sold at $40 a foot in January. 115 Caroline Ave. sold at $46 a foot in the July transfers, with 2,412 square feet.

The weekly deed lists syracuse.com publishes for Onondaga County show who is buying at the bottom of the range. In the list for deeds registered Oct. 29 to Nov. 5, 139 Caroline Ave. went to a limited liability company for $73,000. In the list for Sept. 17 to 24, 310 Second St. sold for $131,250, and both the seller and the buyer were LLCs. Some low entries are also partial interests, where one property is recorded as more than one deed in the same week.

Company purchases and partial deeds are part of the public record, but they are a poor guide to what a household buying a house to live in will pay on that street, and a per-foot average that includes them will make a large house look cheaper than it is likely to be for that buyer.

Using the numbers on a Solvay-area listing

On these streets, two listings at the same asking price can differ by a thousand square feet or more, so compare them as complete houses rather than by the foot. The useful questions are how much of the big house is ready to use, how many bathrooms it has, and whether the extra rooms make up for the work they need. The Scarboro Drive record shows how far a single house can move. The same 2,237 square feet sold for $160,000 in the January transfers and $282,000 in August.

For context, the Greater Syracuse Association of Realtors reported a $270,000 median sale price for September 2026 across its six-county Central New York region, with 2,262 homes on the market at month's end. The Solvay district's September median, Bury Drive at $260,100, was close to that regional figure. Within the district, how much house that money buys ranged from about 1,000 square feet to about 3,000.

Monthly costs are the other half of the comparison, and our look at what the "Solvay Electric" line on a listing means covers one piece of that. The Geddes neighborhood page has the wider picture of the town.

FAQ

Is price per square foot useless in Geddes?

It's useful for comparing houses of similar size and age. Across very different sizes it tells you less. 2026 sales in the Solvay district ran from $35 to $270 a foot, and much of that spread came from dividing similar prices by very different footprints.

Are the big older houses on the numbered streets a bargain?

Per foot, they cost less. Whether that adds up to a good deal depends on the house itself. In this year's sales, the large houses that brought the highest per-foot prices had four bathrooms, while the ones under $130 a foot had one to three.

If you're comparing a compact Westvale-area house with a larger one near Milton Avenue, Lori Harrington can set both against this year's recorded Solvay-area sales and show you what each price is paying for. If you own one of these homes and want to know where it falls in that range, start with a home valuation, and when you're ready, let's connect.

Work With Lori

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram