Cappuccino and a breakfast pastry on an oak cafe table beside a tan banquette and a window overlooking late-autumn trees.

The Hilltop on Route 20 Is Coming Back, With Duckpin Bowling, a Coffee Bar and a Restaurant Called Sprig

The building sits on West Genesee Street, right outside the village on Route 20. It has been closed since November 2021. The restaurant portion has been torn down, and Woodbine has been restoring and transforming the old bowling building.

Its new name is Hilltop Skaneateles. The Citizen reported that the developer, Syracuse-based Woodbine Hospitality Group, set a late-November opening target, which lands about five years to the day after the old Hilltop served its last customer.

The new version is more than a refreshed copy of the old place. It takes the two things the original did and gives each one its own business, then adds two more.

What the old Hilltop was for

The original site had two halves. In its 2021 coverage of the closing, syracuse.com described the Hilltop as a popular local hangout and breakfast spot, and Cedar House as a place to bowl and have a drink. WSYR has dated the bowling alley building to the 1960s. Sean Mott, the owner and operator, wrote in November 2021 that he had been part of the community for "almost 32 years."

The buyer that fall was Woodbine. At the time of the sale, the company said it planned to keep the bowling and restaurant-and-bar uses and expand them. Both businesses closed that November after more than 30 years.

That 2021 plan is the clearest guide to what is on the hill now. The bowling and the bar are back. The breakfast stop is back too, in a new form. Each of them now has its own name and its own room.

Two jobs, four businesses

Here is how the old site's roles map onto the new one, using the components Woodbine lists for the property.

The old Hilltop Hilltop Skaneateles What it offers
Breakfast spot and hangout Hilltop Coffee Specialty drinks and grab-and-go breakfast
Cedar House: bowl and have a drink Hilltop Social & The Taproom Duckpin bowling, golf simulators, billiards, darts, sports on TV, its own food menu, New York beers, wines and ciders
No equivalent Sprig A restaurant serving globally inspired food, with a curated wine program
No equivalent Hilltop Hotel 20 rooms in Hilton's Outset Collection

The two halves that people remember come back as separate businesses, with breakfast moving to the coffee bar and the bowling and drinks moving to the Social. Sprig and the hotel are the parts the old Hilltop never had.

The bowling comes back as duckpin

Of everything on the site, Cedar House carries over most directly. In March 2026, WSYR described the plan as four bowling lanes, three golf simulators, an arcade and a beer-tasting room. The Citizen's later report says the lanes are duckpin and lists billiards and darts, plus TVs for sports and a food menu separate from the restaurant's.

Woodbine calls the Social a recreation hall, and its taproom pours New York producers. The Citizen describes the drink list as New York State beers, wines and ciders. In the March report, WSYR said 42 North Brewing, a Western New York company, would run the beer-tasting room.

Four duckpin lanes add up to a much smaller bowling floor than a traditional alley. With simulators, billiards and darts in the same hall, the plan reads as a games room with a bar. That fits the old Cedar House described in 2021, a place to bowl and have a drink.

Sprig is the part the old Hilltop never had

The old Hilltop was known for breakfast. Sprig is a full restaurant with its own bar. WSYR reported that the restaurant will have about 60 seats and a bar, with plenty of outdoor dining planned for the site. Woodbine describes Sprig as "an elevated restaurant featuring globally inspired cuisine and a thoughtfully curated wine program."

The best clue to how Woodbine runs a restaurant is north of the village on Mottville Road. Skaneateles Fields Resort & Spa sits on a 100-acre site at 1000 Mottville Road, and its rooms and restaurants opened on September 19, 2025. Its main dining room, Fields, serves seasonal, locally sourced food under executive chef Esperanza Guzman.

In September 2026, syracuse.com reported that Fields had made Travel + Leisure's list of the 25 best hotel restaurants in the world. The magazine pointed to Guzman's koji-aged chicken, the kitchen's relationship with nearby Tap Root Fields, and a wine list with 65 Finger Lakes labels.

Fields shows what this developer has already built in town: a dining room that leans on nearby farms and Finger Lakes wine, and that drew national attention within its first year.

One developer on both edges of the village

Hilltop is the latest of several Woodbine projects in Skaneateles. According to The Citizen, the company bought the Skaneateles Suites bungalows and boutique hotel in 2021, the same year it bought the Hilltop. It then bought the Whispering Winds Motel in 2022 and The Allyn Lodge in 2025, and opened the 88-room Skaneateles Fields in fall 2025.

Most of those properties are lodging. Hilltop adds 20 rooms of its own. In the March report, WSYR called them the Hilltop Lofts. The Citizen calls the hotel Hilltop Hotel and reports that it is part of Hilton's Outset Collection, taking bookings from December 11 onward.

The other three pieces work differently from the rooms. A coffee counter, a games hall with a taproom and a 60-seat dining room serve people who live nearby as much as anyone staying the night. Woodbine's own description of the project, as quoted by The Citizen:

"a gathering place for a new generation"

The project also took longer than planned. WSYR has followed it for three years, and Woodbine president Tom Fernandez told the station he had hoped to open in fall 2025, but the old building brought challenges. The March 2026 update moved the target to that summer. The Citizen's report moved it again, to late November.

Planning a first visit

For a first visit to the hill:

  1. Check for opening news first. The official site, hilltopskaneateles.com, has a sign-up for opening updates and links to the venue's Instagram and Facebook accounts.
  2. Pick the part of the building that fits the time of day. Hilltop Coffee covers the breakfast hours the old Hilltop was known for. The Social and its taproom cover an evening of games. Sprig is the sit-down restaurant.
  3. Book the hotel through Hilton. For family coming in for the holidays, the Hilltop Skaneateles hotel page is where bookings from December 11 onward are listed.
  4. Plan a Woodbine dinner on Mottville Road too. Fields at Skaneateles Fields began taking public diners without a room booking after October 1, 2025.

The Hilltop's old breakfast crowd and its Cedar House bowlers will find their places on the same hill again, now with two new neighbors on the site, Sprig and a 20-room hotel.

If the lights coming back on at the top of Route 20 have you thinking about how the west side of Skaneateles is changing, I'd be glad to share what I'm seeing around town. Reach out to Lori Harrington and let's connect over coffee, on the hill or anywhere you like.

Work With Lori

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram